0:00
(upbeat music)
0:02
- We're here at Consensus for another special interview.
0:13
I'm joined by Coinbase, C-L-O, Paul Grohl.
0:17
Paul, it's fantastic to finally meet you in person.
0:19
I've been in the industry for a long time,
0:20
so it's nice to finally sit down with you.
0:22
I think first and foremost,
0:24
let's talk about the biggest sort of news piece
0:26
that has happened, and that was, you know,
0:28
Senator Tom Willis and Angela also Brooks,
0:30
issuing a statement on the Clarity Act,
0:33
and for our audience, and perhaps people
0:35
that haven't been so clued into what's going on,
0:38
can you talk about their statement
0:40
and what's actually happening with the Clarity Act
0:41
going forward, and why this might be
0:43
very good news for our industry.
0:45
- I'm happy to do that, but before I do,
0:46
let me first say thank you for having us,
0:48
it's a pleasure to meet you in person as well.
0:50
With the compromise that was crafted by Senator Tillis
0:54
and Senator Alsobrods, his focus on rewards
0:58
and striking a balance between the important value
1:01
that rewards serves in the stable coin,
1:03
indeed the broader crypto economy,
1:05
and concerns raised by the traditional banking industry,
1:10
however, groundless and meritless,
1:12
and nevertheless needed to be addressed.
1:14
And what the compromise ultimately holds
1:16
is that rewards issued by intermediaries,
1:20
including coin-based, but also including many others,
1:24
may not be based simply on a balance in an account,
1:28
what the banks have sometimes referred to as idle yield.
1:31
Critically though, critically,
1:33
the compromise protects and preserves the ability
1:36
of intermediaries to offer rewards
1:38
that are based on activity on platforms such as ours,
1:42
and those activity-based rewards are critically important
1:45
to encouraging incentivizing adoption of stable coins,
1:50
and their use in all sorts of different circumstances.
1:54
So we think that Senator Tillis
1:55
and Senator Alsobrods have recognized
1:57
that two things can be true at the same time.
2:00
Compromise sometimes from Washington, maybe you require,
2:02
but it's also critically important
2:04
that we not discourage the adoption
2:06
of this important new technology
2:08
in the form of payment stable coins,
2:09
or its use in all sorts of cases
2:11
that we think will be greatly beneficial
2:13
to the American public.
2:14
- Brian Armstrong in January was pretty outspoken about,
2:17
like, no, we're not gonna support the Clarity Act
2:20
in its current form because the banking lobby
2:23
has co-opted it in some way.
2:26
They've made sure that their interests were kept protected.
2:30
Like from the outside looking in as a layman,
2:33
I fundamentally believe that you should actually just be able
2:36
to hold stable coins in a savings account
2:39
and earn yield on it,
2:40
but the banks in the US don't want that to happen.
2:45
Why?
2:46
- Well, Brian Armstrong, our CEO,
2:48
has been clear from the very beginning.
2:50
It's critically important that we protect rewards
2:54
and protect stable coins
2:55
because they do offer such potential
2:58
for radical change in our financial system.
3:00
Now, the banks have worked very hard,
3:03
and particularly their trade associations have worked very hard
3:06
to undermine the adoption of rewards,
3:08
and to rely upon the claim
3:10
that somehow by paying rewards to stable coin holders,
3:15
somehow their balances are at risk.
3:19
They refer to this sometimes as the deposit flight risk.
3:22
There's zero evidence of this.
3:23
I can't underscore enough that when pushed,
3:25
the banks in meeting after meeting,
3:27
in conversation after conversation,
3:29
many of which I participated in personally,
3:31
they produce nothing of substance
3:33
to substantiate this argument.
3:36
Nevertheless, they have felt very strongly
3:39
that this was a red line,
3:40
and so they negotiated quite hard.
3:43
I think it's important, though,
3:44
for the bank trades to finally take yes for an answer.
3:47
Senator Tillis, Senator Alsabrooks have heard their concerns.
3:51
They've crafted a reasonable compromise,
3:53
which doesn't give crypto everything it wants,
3:55
doesn't give the banking trades everything that they want,
3:58
but at the same time recognizes
4:00
that these two different competing interests
4:02
can be accommodated in ways
4:03
that ultimately serve the American public.
4:05
And so I very much encourage the banking trades
4:08
to not snatch defeat from the jaws of victory,
4:12
accept yes for the answer, and move on.
4:15
Yeah, I think compromise is the best word,
4:18
but it still puzzles me that we've both fantastic infrastructure
4:23
that has solved a lot of pain points
4:25
that tradfi should really recognize,
4:28
but I guess it's the fear
4:31
that something new is going to replace something old.
4:34
I think that's right, Gareth,
4:34
but I think it's also important to recognize
4:37
that the most forward-looking forward-leaning among banks
4:41
and other traditional financial institutions
4:43
are themselves adopting the technology
4:44
or indeed looking to adopt it in short order.
4:47
It's one of the reasons why I think it is very much
4:50
in the banks and their trade association's interests,
4:53
not that they need advice from me,
4:55
to accept this compromise and move on,
4:57
because of course, if they do not,
4:59
they will have no standing to compete in this marketplace.
5:02
And genius in its full scope will remain the law of the land.
5:07
And of course, under genius, any reward can be offered
5:10
by any non-issue or for any purpose.
5:12
And I don't think that's what the banks want,
5:14
at least that's what they claim.
5:16
You've been around for a long time in this industry,
5:18
and I mean, we've all seen a huge amount of change.
5:21
We were talking, all fear, about all these old institutions.
5:24
And I remember, you know, three years ago,
5:26
being at the World Economic Forum,
5:28
sitting in a panel with Brian Armstrong on stage,
5:32
alongside people like Ken Leshecha,
5:35
Kanyakos, the South African Reserve Bank governor.
5:38
And I was the person that posed the question to them,
5:40
being like, you know, what's going to happen
5:42
with the Bitcoin Reserve?
5:43
Do you foresee this happening?
5:45
And Brian gave such an eloquent answer,
5:48
on, you know, on stage at wealth,
5:50
in a place where they've just avoided talking about Bitcoin
5:53
for a very long time.
5:54
And then South Africa's Reserve Bank governor gave an answer
5:56
that suggested that he didn't quite understand
5:59
what Bitcoin is and how it works.
6:00
Fast forward to 2026.
6:02
The same thing happened again this year
6:04
where Brian Armstrong was on stage,
6:05
and he spoke very eloquently about Bitcoin,
6:08
and then Francis Central Bank governor
6:10
really made himself also look like he didn't really know
6:14
much about Bitcoin.
6:15
How long does it take until these people
6:17
at the top of, you know, the financial system
6:20
really recognize Bitcoin for what it is?
6:22
Do you think it's going to happen?
6:24
- I recognize it can be frustrating
6:25
for many in the crypto community
6:27
to hear incomplete descriptions of Bitcoin
6:31
and other cryptocurrencies and the technology that underlie them.
6:36
I understand it can be amusing, in some cases,
6:40
to hear them display a certain ignorance
6:42
about how these technologies and asset classes
6:45
can solve real problems for real people.
6:47
But I also think it's important for the crypto community
6:49
to recognize that this conversation is taking place at all.
6:52
I mean, it wasn't that long ago
6:53
that you would never heard the word Bitcoin uttered
6:57
at a meeting of the world economic forum
7:00
or among central bankers from all over the world.
7:02
So the fact that the conversation taking place,
7:03
I think is somewhat remarkable.
7:06
But even more remarkable than that is that we're seeing now
7:09
in all sorts of institutions all over the world
7:13
that previously had very little appetite for crypto,
7:16
real engagement with how this technology can solve problems
7:20
that their economic systems currently face.
7:23
And I think it's wonderful to see that nowhere
7:26
is that more true than here in the United States
7:28
where we have a chairman of the SEC in Paul Atkins,
7:31
a chairman at the CFTC in Mike Sealy,
7:34
who not only get what this technology is about
7:36
but are indeed champions themselves
7:38
of using it to modernize an American financial system
7:42
that has long lagged behind its full potential.
7:44
So I actually choose to view this situation as encouraging
7:49
and optimistic, even though I recognize that
7:51
in certain moments it can feel like we're still
7:54
having old debates around old fears.
7:57
>> No, well, I mean, I echo your sentiments
7:59
and when I was there in 2024
8:02
and I got the opportunity to put my hand up,
8:04
that's why I did because I don't think anyone had spoken
8:06
about Bitcoin inside with ever.
8:08
So it was great to finally like like the spark
8:11
that got that going.
8:12
>> Who does to you for finally raising initiative
8:14
ignored for many years?
8:16
>> I mean, my heart was in my throat
8:17
'cause I thought someone might take the microphone away
8:19
from me as soon as I mentioned Bitcoin,
8:20
but that didn't happen.
8:22
I wanted to talk to you just about the US landscape.
8:24
Obviously so much has changed between two different
8:27
governments running the country
8:29
and it's been a very promising and flourishing two years
8:36
for our industry.
8:38
At the same time, there's been a lot of question marks
8:40
around the Trump's influence and I guess
8:44
misaligned incentives and perhaps some people
8:46
taking advantage of their political position.
8:49
Does that concern you at all that these things
8:51
kind of happen and some of the allegations
8:53
that get thrown around by politicians
8:56
playing around in the crypto space?
8:57
>> Well, I understand the concerns that give rise
9:00
to at least certain allegations that have been made,
9:02
but I think it's also important to recognize
9:04
that to the extent there are concerns about misuse
9:08
or abuse of this particular technology and asset class,
9:13
it's no different than misuse and abuse
9:14
of all sorts of other asset classes that have been
9:16
taking place for really time since time immemorial.
9:20
I think it's critically important that cryptocurrency
9:24
be given a fair chance to compete on the global stage.
9:29
Not an advantaged chance, not a disadvantaged chance,
9:34
but simply a fair and equal unbalanced chance
9:37
to show that it can solve real problems
9:39
in ways that have never been solved before.
9:41
I think that the more sensible among those in Washington
9:44
and I recognize that sensibility among Washingtonians
9:47
is not always recognized by the wider American public
9:50
will ultimately prevail.
9:51
And I do think that if policy makers and regulators alike
9:56
continue to focus on what will keep America strong,
9:59
what will allow to continue to compete globally
10:01
against a rising power in China?
10:04
What will allow the American people to continue to flourish?
10:07
They're going to get to the right answer
10:09
on almost every question regarding crypto and Bitcoin
10:12
that they confront.
10:13
- Let's talk about prediction markets
10:15
'cause it's been so interesting.
10:17
A few weeks back, I chatted to Ben Zhao,
10:19
who's the CEO of Bybit.
10:21
And he was like, I would love to be in that business,
10:23
but I don't have, I just don't have the ability to do it.
10:28
I don't have the clearances.
10:29
I would need to go and get loads of licenses
10:31
from different places in the world
10:33
to start playing in poly markets field, as it were.
10:38
Can you explain a little bit the landscape
10:40
of these markets in the US, what the difficulty is
10:42
in offering these products or services in different states
10:45
and where you see this going?
10:47
Because it's clear, like, poly market is so big now.
10:49
It's different.
10:50
I didn't see it going this way,
10:52
but it's undeniably big and it seems like
10:56
it's gonna take over conventional gambling markets
10:58
and that kind of stuff.
10:59
Well, the US landscape is quite complex
11:03
and it's complex for a number of reasons.
11:06
Perhaps the most important reason is that Congress
11:10
made it very clear that to the extent
11:12
that event contracts involving any number of topics,
11:15
whether politics, sports, whatever,
11:17
that are listed on CFTC registered exchanges
11:22
are the exclusive purview,
11:23
or subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the CFTC.
11:27
Now, certain state governments at the same time
11:30
have taken what we believe to be a misguided view
11:33
that somehow their traditional authority
11:35
to regulate gaming somehow trumps
11:38
that explicit mandate from Congress.
11:42
Unfortunately, conversation and discussion alone
11:44
hasn't been enough to resolve this question.
11:46
So who have seen now lawsuit after lawsuit filed
11:50
in state and federal courts all across the United States
11:53
on this question of who has the right
11:55
to regulate this particular new form of asset class?
12:00
But I think that it's important for everyone to understand
12:03
that it's often the case that courts are required
12:06
to step in when there are these debates
12:08
about federal versus state jurisdiction.
12:10
I'm ultimately an optimist
12:12
that the courts are going to get to the right result.
12:14
We've seen court decisions go in many different directions,
12:17
but the bottom line is that when Congress is explicit
12:21
that a particular type of asset, in this case swaps,
12:25
is so broad as to sweep in a particular type of offering,
12:30
which in this case are event contracts,
12:33
that is the law of the land.
12:35
And in this case, that means
12:36
that these event contracts must be regulated
12:39
by the CFTC and CFTC alone.
12:41
- Why do you think prediction markets are important?
12:44
What are they doing that conventional gambling wasn't doing?
12:49
- Well, I think what prediction markets offer
12:52
is a unique insight and signal
12:56
into popular sentiment that has never been possible before.
13:00
If you think back to where I think prediction markets
13:04
truly had the breakout moment,
13:05
which was the November 2024 presidential election
13:07
here in the States, poll after poll after poll
13:12
predicted that the Democratic nominee,
13:15
Vice President Harris would win.
13:16
And of course, we now know that was not accurate.
13:19
And in fact, really the only market signal
13:22
which identified Donald Trump
13:24
as the likely winner of that election was
13:26
the prediction markets, which address that topic.
13:29
So I think the proof was in that pudding
13:31
and that got people quite excited
13:33
about the ability of prediction markets
13:35
to do all sorts of things and provide insights
13:36
and all sorts of topics that go far beyond
13:38
just one presidential election in one particular year.
13:41
Now, I think that prediction markets also offer advantages
13:45
above and beyond traditional gaming,
13:48
even when they concern subject matter,
13:50
which may overlap, for example, sporting events.
13:53
The fact is that with prediction markets
13:55
on CFTC registered changes, you have peer-to-peer trading.
13:58
You don't have a bet being laid against a casino
14:02
or sports book where the house has an advantage
14:04
in almost every case.
14:06
And you also have just a better customer experience,
14:09
a better UX, a better product overall
14:12
that obviously a lot of Americans
14:14
are quite excited about.
14:15
So I think the market is going to have a lot of say
14:18
in the end as to how all of these regulatory issues
14:22
get resolved because, of course,
14:23
I don't think any wise policy maker can ignore
14:26
the wishes of tens of millions of people
14:29
all across the U.S. who are racing
14:31
into these particular products.
14:35
But I think it's going to take a while
14:36
for the course to sort all that and name
14:38
and take the Supreme Court to issue the final word.
14:41
>> My final question to you,
14:42
just in terms of Coinbase's future,
14:44
it's undeniable that what Coinbase has built
14:47
has fundamentally influenced
14:49
the entire cryptocurrency ecosystem.
14:52
And it will continue to do so.
14:54
You yourself, I United States, you offer your air.
14:56
I think you've been a fantastic champion
14:57
for the industry in general.
14:58
But I've asked many different
15:01
cryptocurrency exchange CEOs.
15:03
Do they see these platforms being the banks of the future,
15:08
the stock exchanges of the future,
15:10
the prediction markets of the future?
15:13
Like if we're all building everything apps,
15:15
who wins that race?
15:17
And why do you think it might be Coinbase?
15:18
>> Well, I definitely think it will be Coinbase,
15:21
not surprisingly.
15:22
And we are certainly focused entirely on building
15:26
an everything app and everything exchange
15:28
that meets our customers where they live
15:30
and that offers a better experience
15:31
than anything else out in the marketplace.
15:33
I think part of the reason why this vision
15:35
of the future is the correct one
15:37
is that over time Gareth,
15:39
we're seeing that consumers, investors and others
15:43
no longer distinguish between these different types
15:46
of products and services or markets
15:48
in the ways that they might have just a short time ago.
15:52
The fact of the matter is that trading
15:54
in prediction markets for many
15:57
is simply alternative to trading in crypto,
16:00
which itself is alternative to trading in equities
16:02
and bonds and all sorts of other financial instruments.
16:05
And so if that's where the consuming
16:08
and investing public is,
16:10
and it's critically important that the companies
16:12
and others who are racing to meet the demands
16:15
of that public, provide them with the products
16:18
and services that they expect
16:19
and that's what we absolutely are focused on doing.
16:21
>> My loss loss question to you,
16:23
the clarity act, when do we actually see this going through?
16:26
>> I'm very confident we're going to see
16:27
the 30 act past this summer at the latest.
16:30
>> Can I hold you to it?
16:31
(laughing)
16:32
>> Well, maybe even get back together
16:33
and we can see if I was right or wrong,
16:34
but I think I'm right.
16:35
>> Well, maybe there's a prediction market for it.
16:37
I'm sure there is.
16:38
Paul, thank you so much for your pleasure.
16:40
>> Pleasure.
16:41
(upbeat music)
16:45
(upbeat music)
Reply